The Source of our Doctrine: Apostles or Church Councils?

By | November 25, 2010

What Douglas Moo writes concerning Peter’s declaration that Jesus is God (2 Pet 1:1) seems to be the standard view:

While it would be a gross anachronism to attribute to the apostle at this point a fully worked-out Trinitarian understanding of God, what he says here, along with other similar verses in the New Testament, provides the building blocks for the later elaboration of that central Christian doctrine.

Essentially the view is that later believers in the church developed the understanding of the Trinity by synthesizing all of the related verses of Scripture. 

But what this seems to suggest is that our understanding of the Trinity is superior to the apostles ‘ understanding.  And yet, our understanding derives from what they taught.

Maybe you could say it this way: Peter understood a slice of the pie but in the course of the next hundreds of years the church put all of the slices together to come with our doctrine.

But if Peter only knew “a slice,” how do I know that he got that “slice” right?  (I’m going to deny here that he wrote truth that he didn’t intend or understand.)

Is it not preferable to believe that Peter (and the other apostolic writers of Scripture) had a full and firm grasp of the doctrine of the Trinity and it was on that basis that they could confidently make statements such as “our God and Saviour Jesus Christ”?

It’s true that later believers in the church were compelled to come up with a systematic formulation of these truths because of false teachers.  But that does not seem to entail that they were the first ones to understand them.  Their belief was that they were simply holding forth the apostolic teaching.

An Inexpressible and Glorious Joy

By | November 23, 2010

According to the Bible, saving faith is:

A. Having believed in Jesus at some point in your life

B. Always knowing that God is real and Jesus is his Son and that he died on the cross for you

C. Primarily demonstrated by doing good works and being a good person

D. Though you have not seen him, you love him; and even though you do not see him now, you believe in him and are filled with an inexpressible and glorious joy (1 Peter 1:8)

November 18

By | November 18, 2010

I’m off for the weekend to Lake Texoma.  Try and guess where that is.  No, it’s not anywhere close to Texarkana.  And it’s a very far distance from Texico.  I’m sure glad that Texas doesn’t share a border with Wisconsin.

Does the kibbutz have a future?  The Jerusalem Post looks backwards and forwards on the 100th anniversary of the institution.

Guess where: “Nowhere do more people meekly acquiesce to more useless inconvenience and needless indignity for less purpose.”  Read the whole thing.

Is the Sabbath Still Required for Christians?  I think this explanation by Tom Schreiner pretty much nails it.

You get can most of John Piper’s books in pdf format for free at Desiring God.  You almost get the sense that he’s more interested in getting the word out than in making money.

Christian Audio is selling near all of their audiobooks for $7.49 (until 12/3).

This may be the best telling of the story of Jonah you’ve ever heard.

A Second 2011 Calendar

By | November 16, 2010

I mentioned here last month a new 2011 calendar.  Sarah just saw it for sale at Office Depot.  Let me know if there are any other sightings.

Another group has used my photos for a 2011 calendar.  Produced by Lion and the Lamb Ministries, the theme of this one is “Gates of the Old City of Jerusalem.”  Perhaps you have (or remember) their 2010 calendar of Church Buildings of Israel.  Unlike the first calendar (by Orange Circle), they gave me a number of free copies.  If you would like one, let me know your name and address below.  If there are too many requests, I ‘ll choose the odd ones (or multiples of three or something like that).  You can also purchase these directly from the organization for $5 plus shipping.

I’m happy that both organizations mentioned above have already planned 2012 calendars with me.  Photos for the first have already been chosen, and photo selection for the second is underway.  I guess some people like to work ahead!

2011 Calendar

So Speak, Isaiah

By | November 13, 2010

One of my favorite “Christmas” albums of all time is Behold the Lamb of God, by Andrew Peterson.  I put “Christmas” in quotation marks because unlike all other Christmas albums, I listen to this one year round.  That’s because it captures the heart of Christmas, which is not a glory limited to one day a year (or to one shopping season).  If Christmas is only about the birth of a special baby, you ‘ll tire of celebrating it after a few weeks.  But if Christmas is the arrival of the hope of the ages, the fulfillment of the dreams of the prophets, the answer to the prayers of the faithful, it is a weight that exceeds a momentary remembrance.Behold the Lamb of God, Andrew Peterson

Christmas is richer if you’ve been “waiting” for the Savior.  But you can’t really get that from the New Testament alone.  If you want to enjoy Christmas more, hang out with the prophets.  Agonize over your sin and the sin of your people.  Anticipate a long, dark exile.  Search the counsel of God for some hint of deliverance. I like this album so much because Andrew Peterson has lived with Moses and David and the prophets.  He understands what they ‘re saying and he communicates that well in his music.

I ‘ll just point you to one song tonight: “So Long, Moses.”  If I had known of this song when it came out, I would have played it for my History of Ancient Israel class every semester (assuming I was less ignorant then than I really was).  You can buy the 6-minute song at Amazon for $.99.  The entire album (13 songs x 2) is $8.99.  You can listen to this song at Youtube here.  And read the lyrics here.  One song cannot capture everything, but this one speaks well of the longings of the people and the hope of the Messiah.

That I’m studying Isaiah 53:4-6 this weekend, that I listened to the whole chapter five times on my way to pick up the boys, and that this song just happened to be on the short playlist on the way home made it especially meaningful tonight.

[I’ve mentioned Peterson before here and here.]

November 11

By | November 11, 2010

PC or Mac?  Here’s a new one.

I’m not really sure what a “neutral” article on the Arab-Israeli conflict would like look, but this one earns points for saying things that you won’t read elsewhere.

This is an impressive 2-minute Timescapes video.

How to raise boys who read – is the secret gross books?

These photos give new perspective to “The high mountains belong to the wild goats” (Ps 104:18).

For a limited time, you can get the VeggieTales Christmas album free from Amazon mp3.

Netanyahu’s Speech at the UN

By | November 9, 2010

I’m probably breaking some blogging rule by linking to something that didn’t happen this week (or even this year), but I just saw this and thought that it might have escaped the notice of others as well. 

Last year Benjamin Netanyahu, prime minister of Israel, addressed the United Nations, one day after a punk from Iran had the same honor.  I think his speech says many things well about the current situation.  You have the option of reading it or watching it (4 parts).

Here’s one portion:

The jury is still out on the United Nations, and recent signs are not encouraging. Rather than condemning the terrorists and their Iranian patrons, some here have condemned their victims. That is exactly what a recent UN report on Gaza did, falsely equating the terrorists with those they targeted.

For eight long years, Hamas fired from Gaza thousands of missiles, mortars and rockets on nearby Israeli cities. Year after year, as these missiles were deliberately hurled at our civilians, not a single UN resolution was passed condemning those criminal attacks.  We heard nothing – absolutely nothing – from the UN Human Rights Council, a misnamed institution if there ever was one.

And another:

Inscribed on the walls outside this building is the great Biblical vision of peace: "Nation shall not lift up sword against nation.  They shall learn war no more." These words were spoken by the Jewish prophet Isaiah 2,800 years ago as he walked in my country, in my city, in the hills of Judea and in the streets of Jerusalem.  We are not strangers to this land.  It is our homeland.

4 Inches

By | November 5, 2010

That’s the height of the stack of papers on my desk.  I remember when I was a kid and a babysitter said she had to write a 30-page paper.  I was in awe.  Since that time, I’ve written many papers.  Most of them took me less time to research and write than the current one took me to (lightly) proofread (two weeks).  Some of them were started and finished in less time than it took me to print this one (1.5 days).

The total page count is 895.  That’s the least important fact about it, but it is the easiest symbol of the size of the project.  I started in mid-January and I finished the first draft in mid-July.  I worked about 40 hours a week, every week.  My schedule prevented me from proofreading and printing until recently, but today it is done.  About 2/3 of the way through the printing, I realized that my bibliographic program caused a last-minute error on every page.  Should I go back and reprint 600 pages?  I think not.  My footnote separator bar likes being indented by an inch.

So when can you get a copy?  Never.  It may sound strange, but the fact of the matter is that though I’ve never spent so much time on any school project in my life, I am not at all proud of it.  I always felt rushed.  The goal was always to meet the next (self-imposed) deadline.  If I missed one, it was cutting into the time on the next book.  What can I possibly say that is better than those who have studied some of these books all of their lives?  Nothing.  But was the project worthwhile?  Absolutely.  But only as a beginning and not as an ending.  It’s not only what is on the page, but what is in my head.  I see the pieces better now, and I see the big picture better.  I still have a long ways to go, but I feel that I took a monumental leap forward in the process. 

On Monday, I ‘ll be back in the New Testament, starting with my last Pauline epistle—2 Timothy.  I need to finish Hebrews to Revelation by December 17.  More good times ahead.

Another Reason to Study Your Bible

By | November 3, 2010

I found John Piper’s recent message from his National Conference to be very good and I would recommend that you listen to it.  The title is “The Life of the Mind and the Love of God.” Here is one quote:

There is an odd notion that, if we use our minds to grow in our knowledge of God, mystery will diminish and with it a sense of wonder and reverence. I call this notion odd for two reasons. One is that, no matter how many millions of ages I use my mind to know more and more of God’s majesty, his glories will never be in danger of being exhausted. What is not yet known of God by finite creatures will always be limitless. You honor this truth more by shameless growth in the knowledge of God.

And the second reason I find the notion odd that thinking about God and knowing more and more of God jeopardizes our worship of God, is that without knowing him we can’t worship in a way that honors him. God is not honored when people get excited about how little they know of him.

Piper doesn’t directly call people to read their Bibles; his is a message encouraging thought.  But the best thinking must be rooted in the Scriptures.  There is no knowledge of God apart from his revelation of himself.  “Shameless growth in the knowledge of God” means less football and more Bible study, less exercise and more Scripture reading, less socializing and more Bible memory.